In a dramatic and closely watched contest, Democrats have scored a major political victory in New Jersey. Representative Mikie Sherrill, a Democrat who rose to national prominence as part of the 2018 “blue wave,” has been projected to win the governor’s race, defeating Republican challenger Jack Ciattarelli. The win is a significant one, cementing Democratic control of the Garden State and dealing a major blow to Republican hopes of reclaiming influence in a traditionally blue but often unpredictable state. The race was called minutes ago by Decision Desk, one of the most reliable election sites in the country.
To keep breaking stories like this, we need your support. Subscribe today to help us stay bold, independent, and louder than ever as we fight to keep the truth alive in these critical times.
Subscribe
Not many expected this outcome. New Jersey’s recent history shows a pattern of alternating party control every eight years: Republican Chris Christie served two terms before Democrat Phil Murphy took over for another eight. With Murphy’s tenure ending, political momentum—and voter fatigue—seemed to favor a Republican resurgence. High property taxes, soaring energy costs, and persistent affordability concerns had many voters frustrated, creating what looked like a perfect opening for the GOP.
But Mikie Sherrill’s campaign defied expectations. She navigated those headwinds with skill, framing her candidacy as a new chapter of pragmatic leadership and renewal for New Jersey Democrats. Her victory marks not just a continuation of her party’s hold on the governor’s mansion, but also a symbolic triumph over the national Republican strategy to rebrand in the second iteration of Trump’s America.
For Republican Jack Ciattarelli, the loss is particularly painful. This was his third attempt to win the governor’s office after falling just short four years ago in a surprisingly close race against Murphy. This time, however, Ciattarelli took a dramatically different approach: he fully embraced Donald Trump and the MAGA movement, hoping to galvanize the Republican base and ride the wave of right-wing populism that has reshaped much of the national GOP.
That strategy, however, appears to have backfired in a state that remains deeply wary of Trump-style politics. Unlike his more moderate tone in 2021, Ciattarelli’s pivot toward the far right alienated many suburban and independent voters—constituencies that had once given him a fighting chance. In the end, his attempt to “go full MAGA” failed to resonate in New Jersey’s diverse and often centrist political landscape.
Sherrill’s victory is a testament to her ability to build a broad coalition that included suburban moderates, independents, and younger voters who remain energized by issues like reproductive rights, gun safety, and education. Her campaign leaned heavily on her reputation as a pragmatic problem solver—a former Navy pilot and federal prosecutor known for her focus on accountability and good governance.
Her messaging also emphasized local concerns, particularly affordability, infrastructure, and property tax relief. Rather than relying solely on national Democratic themes, Sherrill positioned herself as someone who could deliver tangible improvements for New Jersey families, especially in the face of economic uncertainty and political polarization.
Sherrill’s win also breaks a longstanding political cycle in New Jersey. For decades, voters have oscillated between Democratic and Republican governors roughly every eight years. This pendulum effect reflected a kind of institutionalized voter fatigue: a built-in tendency to “throw the bums out” after two terms, regardless of party.
By succeeding Phil Murphy, Sherrill becomes the first Democrat in nearly half a century to win the governorship following another Democrat’s two-term administration—a remarkable feat that underscores both her political skill and the evolving dynamics of New Jersey’s electorate.
Against the odds, Mikie Sherrill has rewritten New Jersey’s political narrative—and perhaps signaled that in an era of deep division, competence and moderation still have a winning appeal.